วันอังคารที่ 19 เมษายน พ.ศ. 2559

The Anarchy in England – A Pointless War with an Unexpected Cause? How Luck, Chance and Fortune messed up our History (Part 1 – Background and Beginning of the War)

Henry I
A sly and clever King, Henry I may have played a
part in his brother's death so that he could take the
throne of England for himself
The story I’m about to tell occurs at the end of Henry I’s reign up till 1154. Many may wonder why I choose this period to write about while ignoring the much more famous and significant 1066 Norman Conquest . Do not fear! I shall write about that soon if time permits (and if you are willing to read it, of course, as opposed to looking up a wealth of information on it out there already). The reason is that this war-ridden period in British history has always fascinated me, caused so unexpectedly as it was by a series of luck and coincidence.

Henry I is the fourth and youngest son of the famous William the Conqueror who established the Norman Dynasty (more about that later!). His older brothers are Robert, Richard and William. Upon their father’s death, Robert was granted the Duchy of Normandy, Richard was already dead at that time (killed in the hunting accident in the New Forest), and William received England and became William II. Henry was, however, left landless, with only a handful of money. Some surmise that Henry got the throne of England by plotting William II’s murder in the New Forest while both of them were out hunting. William II was indeed killed (by a stray arrow shot by Henry’s friend), but whether his death was planned remains uncertain to this day. Indeed, the circumstances of his death are strikingly similar to that of Richard a few decades earlier, making us wonder at this bizarre twist of fate.

William Adelin, son and heir of Henry I
Now you all remember that Henry still has one remaining brother, Robert, Duke of Normandy. Discontent with being a mere Duke and regarding Henry’s claim to the throne of England as unwarranted (Robert is the older and oldest brother after all!!), decided to invade England in 1101. He failed. Both side reached a settlement and Robert returned to Normandy. Henry then invaded Normandy in 1105 and 1106, defeated Robert at the Battle Tinchebray and imprisoned him for the rest of his life. Happy Henry now has both England and Normandy. But still this is not the focus of this blog!

Fast forward to 1116, a major rebellion broke out in Normandy supported by Louis VI of France. Henry and his son William Adelin defeated the French at the battle of Bremule, after which both sides reached a peace settlement whereby William Adelin would be officially invested with the Duchy in 1119.

Matilda, a fiery arrogant daughter of Henry I
It is at this point that I must now digress and talk a little bit about Henry’s two legitimate children. Under the law of royal succession, only legitimate children could ascend the throne of England. Now Henry I had many illegitimate sons and daughters (he took many mistresses!), but no sons could be more important than William Adelin, whose mother is Henry’s Queen, Matilda. His other legitimate child is a daughter named Matilda, whom Henry married to Henry V the Holy Roman Emperor (remember her as she will definitely become a major and significant character later in the story).  Thus Henry I only had one legitimate son, on whom all his hope of establishing a secure line of succession rested. But as you all could have guessed, history always has a nasty surprise and ways of spicing thing up….

Henry I has been so far lucky. He has the throne of England. He successfully quelled the rebellion in Normandy. He defeated the French (always a British pride). His son was now invested with the Duchy of Normandy. If there is only one thing left to achieve before he could rest in peace that would be to see his son ready and well established to be the next English King. However, Henry I will never live to see that day….

Henry is said never to smile again after
the death of his son William Adelin
 after the White Ship disaster
On the evening of 25 November 1120, Henry’s only legitimate son and heir, the 16-year-old William Adelin and his party went aboard the White Ship from Barfleur in Normandy bound for England. The atmosphere was festive. The passengers were drunk. The crew were also drunk. The helmsman was inattentive. As a result, the ship went straight onto a large rock hidden just below the waterline (who could have guessed). The fateful impact sank the ship, bringing down with it the English heir apparent and several other members of the nobility into the deep blue sea (by the way, the coast of England is just in sight!). The only survivor is a butcher from Rouen. Another survivor is Henry I’s nephew, Stephen, Count of Blois, who were suffering from a severe diarrhea and declined to board the White Ship in the last minute (remember him, he is also extremely important!). You see, fate always has a way of complicating things, and it is fate which will ultimately dictate the worldly affairs and the course of history.

The White Ship
The White Ship disaster, itself a mere incident of shipwreck, immediately brought about a succession crisis. Henry’s only remaining legitimate child is Matilda, a daughter. He fathered no other legitimate children in his later years despite having taken a second wife, Queen Adeliza. Matilda, as mentioned earlier, was married to Henry V the Holy Roman Emperor and became Empress. When Henry V died in 1125, she was remarried in 1128 to Geoffrey Count of Anjou. With his heir now dead, in 1127 Henry gathered the barons of the land in Westminster Hall and ordered them to swear fealty that they would uphold Matilda’s succession, a radical step indeed as no woman has ever been crowned as King before in English history.  Stephen of Blois, Henry’s nephew (Stephen is a son of Henry’s sister, Adela), was among those who swore fealty to Matilda. Again, as we will see, Henry could not have foreseen nor controlled all the future complications which were about to arise. Clever men may plot and plan. The powerful may calculate and strategise. But luck and chance will always rule the human affairs in the end.

Stephen of Blois, Henry I's nephew and Matilda's cousin
After Henry’s death, arguably an unthinkable happened. On learning of the King’s death, Stephen of Blois left France, rode straight to London, acclaimed King by the people, and claimed the treasury (yes, the same Stephen who had diarrhea just before he was about to board the White Ship, and yes, the same Stephen who swore an oath to Matilda in 1127). He believed in his luck. After all, he is a grandson of William the Conqueror, and naturally a potential candidate for the English throne in the absence of any royal heirs. He persuaded many leaders of the Kingdom to join his cause and was crowned King in Westminster Abbey on 22 December 1135, three weeks after Henry’s death. The reason for his success indeed stemmed from the unwillingness of the nobility to be governed by a woman. No woman has ever ruled England as a Monarch before and Matilda was known to be arrogant and of imperious temperament given she was Empress since 14 and enjoyed absolute royal power since. What was Matilda then to do? Her throne was snatched from her by a disloyal cousin. Filled with fiery temperament she inherited from her Norman forebears, she arrived in England in 1139 with her supporters and troops, and with her arrival, the beginning of a long struggle between cousins as they fought for the English throne. The Anarchy has begun.



To be continued in the next blog

ไม่มีความคิดเห็น:

แสดงความคิดเห็น