วันศุกร์ที่ 21 ตุลาคม พ.ศ. 2559

Ancient Egypt: A View of the Fourth Dynasty from a Greek Perspective

A lot of our knowledge on ancient Egypt came from the work of Herodotus, a Greek historian who was born in Halicarnassus in the Persian Empire (modern-day Bodrum, Turkey) and lived in the fifth century BC (c. 484–c. 425 BC). Renowned as the “Father of History”, he was the first historian known to have broken from Homeric tradition to treat historical subjects as a method of investigation by collecting his materials systematically and critically and arranging them into a historiographic narrative. In Book Two of The Histories, his masterpiece work, he related the stories of Khufu (“Cheops”) and Khafra (“Chephren”) and Menkaura (“Mycerinus”). These accounts are allegedly told to him by Egyptian priests during his visit to the pyramids in the mid-fifth century BC. Surprisingly, Herodotus described both Cheops and Chephren as tyrants, while Mycerinus was portrayed as a good king.

Account of Khufu’s Reign
Khugfu was portrayed as a Pharaoh who brought Egypt into all sorts of misery. Not only did he close all the temples thereby excluding his subjects from practicing their religion, he also compelled the, to labour as his slaves for his own end (obviously to build his lavish tomb). Details were given of how slaves were forced to bring blocks of stone from the quarries in the Arabian hills to the Nile, where they were further ferried across by others. Herodotus described how the work went in three-monthly shifts, 100,000 men working in each shift. After 10 years, the track along which the blocks were hauled was finally completed. The building of the pyramid itself took 20 years, and, according to Herodotus’ account, it is 5 furlongs (1 km) in length, 60 feet wide and 48 feet high. The pyramid is square at the base, its height equal to the length of each side, and is of polished stone blocks. Interestingly, Herodotus also told us the method the Egyptians employed to construct the pyramid i.e. to build it in steps or as tiers or terraces. When the base was complete, the blocks for the first tier above it were lifted from the ground by contrivances made of short timbers. In this first tier there was another, which raised the blocks on a stage higher, then yet another which raised them higher still. He also recounted how the interpreter helped him decipher the Egyptian inscription so as to ascertain the amount spent on food for the labourers.

“And I remember distinctly that the interpreter who read me the inscription said that the sum was 1,600 talents of silver…”

The account’s climax came when Herodotus alleged that at the end of his money, Cheops sent his daughter to a bawdy house to earn some money! Ironically the sum earned from such shameful transactions was then expended in the construction of the middle pyramid of the three standing in front of the great pyramid. Now whether this story is to be believed is extremely doubtful indeed!

Account of Khafra’s Reign
Cheops ruled for 50 years (according to Herodotus) and was succeeded on his death by his son Khafra (Herodotus said Khafra was Khufu’s brother!). Like Khufu, Khafra was oppressive. His pyramid is of smaller size (40 feet lower than Khufu’s). Herodotus proudly stated that he measured both pyramids himself. Khafra ruled for 56 years. This, said Herodotus, combined with his father’s reign made up a total of 106 years during which temples were never opened for worship and the country reduced to the greatest possible misery. Surely there must be an element of exaggeration in Herodotus’ account as it was usually agreed that Khufu and Khafra’s reigns were among the most prosperous and peaceful of those of the Old Kingdom. 

Account of Menkaura’s Reign
The next king of Egypt to rule after Chephren was Mycerinus, the son of Cheops. Mycerinus, reversing his father’s policy of which he did not approve, reopened all the temples and allowed his subjects, who had been brought into such abject slavery, to resume the practice of their religion and their normal work. Herodotus further commended the king for his reputation for justice in the decision of legal causes, and it was said how Mycerinus used to compensate out of his own property any man who was dissatisfied with the results of his suit. On his only daughter’s death, in his grief he built her a wooden cow, hollow inside and plated on the outside with gold, to receive her body. Herodotus then described how the cow was not buried, but could still be seen by him in Sais, with offering and incense offered before it every day. Another version of the story is that Mycerinus conceived a lust for his daughter and violated her, driving her to hang herself. However, this version seems improbable.

After his daughter’s death, a second calamity fell on Mycerinus. He received an oracle from Buto to the effect he was destined to live for only six more years and to die within the seventh. Mycerinus in retaliation sent an angry message reproaching the god with the injustice of allowing a man so pious as himself to die so soon, whereas the last two kings who had closed the temples, forgotten the gods and afflicted their fellow men, lived to a ripe old age. Convinced his doom was drawing near, he had innumerable lamps made, by the light of which he set himself every evening to drink and be merry, and never ceased by day or ight from the pursuit of pleasure, travelling from place to place amongst the pools and woodlands. His object in this was by turning night into day to extend the six remaining years of his life into twelve, and so convict the oracle of falsehood.


Despite his claim of having visited Egypt, the accuracy of Herodotus’ account remains controversial as clearly it was evident he was working from inadequate sources. Many even accused his account defective and mostly untrue. Indeed, this appears to be the case looking at the above extracts and the exaggeration contained therein on the tyranny of Khufu and Khafra.


ไม่มีความคิดเห็น:

แสดงความคิดเห็น